Best P2E Games

Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin – Sam Barberie

Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin – Sam Barberie

Game Review 

Beware game funding pitfalls: False promises of coins & alternative financing. Learn from mistakes & the allure of game coins. 

Two truths and a lie:

  1. Game development costs a lot of money
  2. Money from game publishers is hard to get 
  3. Launching a coin is a great way to fund a game 

Bravo if you sniffed out number 3 as the boldfaced lie that many of us in blockchain gaming have fallen for over the past few years.  

You might say, “But Sam, it’s 2023. The jig is up and we’ve all realized that coins aren’t a good idea.” You say that now, but…

There have been dozens of ICOs/IDOs over the past year, despite macro conditions. And many more gaming coins are on hold, awaiting a theoretical bull run for such things. The bull is coming, but not for those. Even without the regulatory uncertainty, coins aren’t only a massive distraction and significant threat to a gaming company’s business, but are proving themselves to be long-term bad bets. 

[Obviously none of this is financial advice.] 

First, let’s take a look at why coins seemed so attractive a few years ago: 

  1. For developers, they were a relatively easy way to raise money from a mix of institutions and consumers hopping on the hype train. They were also a way to cash out on vesting faster than traditional equity. 
  2. For investors, the theory was, they were an immediately-liquid form of investment, as opposed to traditional equity which requires some kind of exit (acquisition or IPO). 
  3. For consumers, it was another bout of get-rich-quickery and, not as often, a feeling of “investing” in a game’s future. The degen crypto trader crowd weren’t die-hard gamers, but were willing to make money off them. 

These coins also exposed some odd hypocrisy. In lots of cases, the developers insisted that they would be “utility tokens,” i.e. usable in-game for purchasing items, etc. Which was kind of bizarre coming from a crowd that was against the idea of web2’s closed ecosystems where Fortnite Vbucks had no value in Roblox, for example. These tokens are fungible, and while SAND can be swapped into GALA, each coin universe was essentially saying, “It’s our currency or nada.” Not exactly an open world of seamlessly transferable assets. 

But very quickly, developers and investors alike realized some uncomfortable truths: 

  • Regulations make it incredibly hard to bake in usage for a coin in-game.
    • Not much utility when you can’t use the coin for anything.
    • The investor-y language around the launches puts these coins in even greater regulatory peril as securities.  
  • Coins move relative to the macro crypto market (up until now, we’ll get into this more) and not the usability of the token.
    • The value lives and dies by forces that are uncontrollable. Unlike a stock, where macro conditions can be amazing for some, poor for others (like how leisurewear companies thrived during the pandemic but hotels certainly did not), when crypto winter occurred, every coin went with it. 
  • Coin management and investor relations take significant time away from more important things.
    • A Discord filled with angry consumer investors asking, “Wen moon,” or a marketing plan focused more on pumping token price and not the game, is not a good use of anyone’s time. 
    • If you’ve got good VCs, they normally give you money, provide guidance, and then wait in the wings to offer support when needed. Those are investors game developers want. But consumer token investors want the world, and they want it now. A great way to kill anticipatory excitement. 
    • Lots of developers also set up DAOs or DAO-like structures that would allow for the community of holders to make decisions on game design. Nothing says “this game will be horrible and never launch” quite like design by committee. 
  • Coins don’t reflect the fundamental value of a company.
    • When your company’s market cap is wrapped up in a coin you can’t easily control, compared to equity, it sets up a trough of despair that’s hard to work out of. 
    • Teammates whose compensation includes worthless tokens aren’t going to be extra motivated. 
  • Price fluctuations turn people off.
    • There’s a reason why $1 doesn’t equal 1 Vbuck. That’s just F2P economics 101. 
    • So players already don’t want to see something cost $10, but—even if the coin is doing well—don’t want to see it cost 0.000947 Ape either. One layer of price abstraction is fine. Two is not, especially when it comes with daily changes that users will have to convert themselves (or the developer risks exposing fiat values which won’t be in their economy’s best interest). 

And even as the prices of Bitcoin and Ethereum have started to rally, sentiment still seems sour on early gaming coins, who have all followed similarly poor trajectories in underperforming the market.  

Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin - Sam Barberie
Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin - Sam Barberie 5
Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin - Sam Barberie
Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin - Sam Barberie 6
Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin - Sam Barberie
Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin - Sam Barberie 7

Even if the token price stays decent, coins complicate later investments, exits, and consumer choices:

  • Reducing options for other outside investment.
    • Traditional investors in later rounds might not want to compete with supposed carve-outs for token holders, while coin holders will push back against a two-tier system. 
  • Cutting off acquisition routes.
    • Public companies, especially, don’t want to acquire studios with regulatory baggage. 
  • Consumer expectations.
    • As many games increasingly support multiple chains or use tech like LayerZero, games that stick to their coin economies will be behind the curve of what players expect to see.
    • Likewise with fiat on-ramps and direct purchase trending to the norm, many users won’t expect to see a crypto currency at all. 

Coins aren’t the only alternative fundraising route that developers have tried. Pre-product mints of NFTs, while having some benefits over coins, have largely followed similar trajectories: 

  1. They’re normally bought by investors, not real players.
  2. Their floor prices mimic the larger NFT trading market cycle, not anticipation for the game. 
  3. High initial mint prices always fall dramatically as they converge on a normal game access pass, angering holders. 
  4. Mints also come with the same community management challenges of coins. Lots of TLC for angry voices, not a lot of true community building or development focus. 

But NFTs have some key differences: 

  1. Their regulatory standing (not as likely to be considered securities).
  2. They’re much easier to bring in as fundamentally utile pieces of the game. 

More and more, however, we’re seeing free mints—both limited and unlimited—as a powerful way for developers to rally a community and earn some money through secondary trades. While free or extremely low cost mints don’t net developers the amount of building funds they want, they’re strong indicators of interest that can be put in front of publishers or other investors (similar to web2’s email signups). They also go a long way to build goodwill with future players, reach a larger potential audience in the pre-product phases, and don’t come with the same outsize expectations and distracting maintenance needs as high-priced drops and/or coins. 

The loss of coin launches as a viable option will mean the end for some new studios, full stop. As harsh as it sounds, however, that’s not only expected but also probably as it should be. The world’s best games haven’t been greenlit through speculative investment vehicles. And crowdfunding in general has a dicey history, like Star Citizen’s wildly successful Kickstarter and subsequent $500M in funding, which still hasn’t gotten anyone any playable game in a decade.   

I’m a firm believer that good games can come from anywhere and should have multiple ways of getting made, but I’ll leave you all with this: coins ain’t it. 

Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin - Sam Barberie
Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin – Sam Barberie

Sam Barberie is a gaming and web3 exec based in NY. He was part of the founding team of SuperData Research, which was acquired by Nielsen in 2018; an executive at Animoca Brands; and a consultant and advisor to several blockchain gaming companies. 

Play To Earn Games News

Thanks for taking the time to read this news story on PlayToEarnGames.com. We have all of the latest crypto news about cryptocurrencies, blockchain, web3, and play-to-earn. Our platform is all about keeping you up to date on the newest and best play-to-earn games out there. On our website, you can find in-depth reviews, interesting videos, and detailed articles about the newest and most exciting P2E games for multiple platforms.

We tell you everything you need to know to get the most out of your game time. If you want to learn more about a certain game, you can look at game tokens, white papers, and social media sites that are related to that game.

We are proud to keep our readers up to date on the latest changes in the gaming industry, such as new developments in blockchain technology, non-fungible tokens (NFTs), cryptocurrencies, Web3 innovations, and interesting metaverse games. Check out our “Best Games” and “Game Lists” sections to learn more about the best P2E games and game developers. In the “Video Game News” section, where we post updates every day, you can find out what’s going on in the gaming world.

If you are launching a game or have news about PlayToEarn games, please send us a press release. Our team of dedicated PlayToEarn Game news reporters will be happy to cover your news or event. Our website and reviews of video games are meant to help you find the best play-to-earn (P2E) games out there. We’re glad you chose to come to PlayToEarnGames.com. If you like watching our videos about gaming news or P2E games, you can see them all here. Check out our list of Web3 games to find the one you like best, or the best play to earn games list, or an overview of all the crypto game news 2023.

Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin – Sam Barberie

If you like this game, share it with your friends:

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
WhatsApp
Telegram
Pinterest
Skype
VK
Email

Find our Best P2E Games list. All games are included with reviews and links to the game review page. Have Fun!

More Games

Related P2E Games: Play To Earn Crypto, NFT, Web3

The Football Club – Game Review

The Football Club (FC) is a new play-to-earn NFT metaverse game that brings real-world football teams and players to the world of WEB3. Built on the Flow blockchain, the game is designed to be fast, efficient, and user-friendly, making it easy for football fans to join in and be part of the sports gaming revolution. In The Football Club, players collect and trade NFT collectibles, which are digitally licensed versions of real-world football players. The game is free-to-play, so everyone can become a part of the community, whether they’re seasoned gamers or new to the world of NFTs. As players progress through the game, they can improve their avatar’s lifestyle and progress as a manager by buying and using NFT items. Members of the FCM can also manage their own teams, choosing from a collection of over 1,000 licensed original players. With its combination of real-world football teams, NFT collectibles, and play-to-earn gameplay, The Football Club is set to revolutionize the world of sports gaming and bring a new level of excitement and engagement to football fans everywhere. The Football Club Game Play: “The Football Club”, a play-to-earn NFT metaverse game, is excited to announce the kickoff of weekly tournaments for players. These tournaments offer a chance for players to increase their XP and win coins, which can be used to participate in higher-ranking matches and tournaments. The matches in The FC are played in real-time, and non-participants can join as spectators. The project is a collaboration between Unagi’s fantasy football game and the Arsenal Football Club, with support and investment from DreamCraft Co. Players in “The Football Club” can earn money not only by winning matches, but also by simply participating and increasing their ranks. The game’s in-game currency is $CHAMP, a utility token, while the $MGC token is the main reward for managers in the form of manager contracts.

Read Game Review »

Trial Xtreme Freedom – Game Review

Trial Xtreme Freedom is blockchain-based, compete-to-win, and World’s first Web3-powered, decentralized competitive gaming ecosystem. Experience the ultimate dirt bike racing adventure with Trial Xtreme Freedom. A mobile game that combines high-speed competition with the world of non-fungible tokens (NFTs). The closed alpha launch offers players an opportunity to delve into a decentralized ecosystem where skill-based PvP races and NFT ownership converge. Get ready to embrace the freedom of extreme racing!

Read Game Review »

Angry Ape Army: Primal NFT Warfare – Game Review

In “Angry Ape Army” game, players can breed, train, and equip their apes to create the ultimate army. The apes can be used in various game modes such as wars, tournaments, and more. The game also includes a mining feature where players can collect resources and use them to upgrade their apes. The game is set in a post-apocalyptic world where apes have taken over and are fighting for survival. As players progress through the game, they will uncover the story of how the apes rose to power and their ongoing struggles. With a combination of strategy and luck, players can build the strongest ape army and rise to the top of the leaderboard. According to the developers, the story of Angry Ape Army takes place in a post-apocalyptic world where apes have risen to power and dominate the world. As a player, you will take on the role of a leader of a tribe of apes and must fight to defend your territory against rival tribes. You can breed and train your own unique ape NFTs to use in battle and also collect resources through mining. The game is set to offer a variety of game modes, including PVP and PVE, and will feature a dynamic narrative that evolves over time. It will be interesting to see how the story of the Angry Ape Army plays out and how it will impact gameplay. Angry Ape Army Back Story: The Apes are thought of as very intelligent creatures that have been witnessing what is happening in the world from a distance. They stood there observing in silence as humanity’s greed, hunger, and lust for power were always destructive, never conservative. But the apes act in accordance with their responsibilities as the world’s protectors and come to the aid when the situation is so dire that there is no chance of recovery. Early Buyers will have some edge: The OG Ape holders will have full access to the metaverse from early on and the monkey island with more chances of playing, earning, and mining rewards. There will be a total of 3333 OG NFT Apes on offer. Additionally, all owners of OG Apes will receive complimentary mints for upcoming drops. Moreover, having an OG Ape grants you VIP access to a variety of things, including whitelist chances, merchandise, and unique events.

Read Game Review »

Infinite Drive – Game Review

Infinite Drive is a new game developed by The Tiny Digital Factory, the team behind the popular Revv Racing game. This high-octane driving experience is built on the Solana blockchain network and offers players the chance to test their skills and compete against others in a variety of different modes. Whether you’re a seasoned racing veteran or new to the world of high-speed competition, Infinite Drive has something for everyone. With its immersive gameplay and exciting action, it’s sure to be a hit with players of all skill levels. So why wait? Start your engines and get ready to take on the competition with Infinite Drive! Infinite Drive is a unique combination of play-to-earn and free-to-play gaming, providing access to everyone regardless of their experience or skill level. Developed by a team of veteran game developers from companies like UbiSoft, Infinite Drive is focused on providing a fun and immersive gaming experience rather than simply being a way to make money. As a metaverse, Infinite Drive features its own NFT licensed cars and assets, making the gaming experience feel more realistic and authentic. Whether you’re a seasoned racing veteran or new to the world of high-speed competition, Infinite Drive has something to offer for players of all levels. So why wait? Get behind the wheel and start racing today with Infinite Drive! Infinite Drive Gameplay: The game is a fast-paced racing game that offers both PvE and PvP gameplay options. With over 150 NFT cars from 20 different brands like Mercedes, Renault, Porsche, and more, players have plenty of choices when it comes to customizing, upgrading, and renting their vehicles. The goal is to win races, earn points through social interactions with other players, and explore the metaverse by driving on long trips. As players earn points, they can increase their collection of NFT cars in their garage and climb the leaderboard to claim rewards in tournaments. In addition to solo play, Infinite Drive also allows players to form groups and communities, encouraging socialization and teamwork. Whether you’re a seasoned racing pro or just looking for a fun and exciting new game, Infinite Drive has something for everyone.

Read Game Review »

Best P2E Games list 2024

Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin – Sam Barberie

P2E News, short for “Play-to-Earn News,” is a category of updates and information within the broader spectrum of Crypto News, Web3 News, NFT News, and Blockchain News. These terms are all interconnected and represent various facets of the rapidly evolving digital landscape.

Play-to-Earn (P2E) is a gaming model that has gained immense popularity within the crypto and blockchain communities. In P2E games, players can earn cryptocurrencies or NFTs by participating in the game, often through activities like completing quests, collecting items, or trading assets. P2E News covers developments, announcements, and trends related to these innovative gaming experiences that allow players to monetize their in-game efforts.

Crypto News, on the other hand, focuses on the broader world of cryptocurrencies, including Bitcoin, Ethereum, and a multitude of altcoins. This category encompasses news about market trends, regulatory changes, new blockchain technologies, and updates related to various tokens. Crypto News is a fundamental aspect of the blockchain ecosystem, as cryptocurrencies serve as the primary means of value transfer and exchange within the Web3 space.

Web3 News is an umbrella term that refers to the next-generation internet, often characterized by decentralized applications, blockchain technology, and smart contracts. The Web3 ecosystem seeks to provide a more user-centric and decentralized internet experience. This category of news covers developments in decentralized finance (DeFi), non-fungible tokens (NFTs), and various other applications built on blockchain technology. For the ultimate and best play to earn games list, check our friends of playtoearngames.com.

NFT News focuses on Non-Fungible Tokens, unique digital assets that are indivisible and represent ownership of a specific item, artwork, or collectible. NFTs have gained prominence in the art world, gaming industry, and entertainment sector. NFT News keeps enthusiasts informed about NFT sales, new projects, and partnerships within the NFT space.

Blockchain News pertains to the foundational technology behind cryptocurrencies and Web3 applications. Blockchains are decentralized ledgers that record transactions across a network of computers, ensuring transparency and security. Updates in this category might include innovations in blockchain consensus mechanisms, interoperability between different blockchain networks, and industry applications beyond cryptocurrencies.

In summary, P2E News is a niche subset of Crypto News, Web3 News, NFT News, and Blockchain News. It focuses on gaming experiences where players can earn cryptocurrencies or NFTs, while the other categories encompass a broader range of topics within the decentralized digital landscape, including cryptocurrencies, web3 technologies, NFTs, and blockchain advancements. Collectively, these categories shape the landscape of the digital economy, offering insights into how technology is revolutionizing various aspects of our lives.