Best P2E Games

Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin – Sam Barberie

Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin – Sam Barberie

Game Review 

Beware game funding pitfalls: False promises of coins & alternative financing. Learn from mistakes & the allure of game coins. 

Two truths and a lie:

  1. Game development costs a lot of money
  2. Money from game publishers is hard to get 
  3. Launching a coin is a great way to fund a game 

Bravo if you sniffed out number 3 as the boldfaced lie that many of us in blockchain gaming have fallen for over the past few years.  

You might say, “But Sam, it’s 2023. The jig is up and we’ve all realized that coins aren’t a good idea.” You say that now, but…

There have been dozens of ICOs/IDOs over the past year, despite macro conditions. And many more gaming coins are on hold, awaiting a theoretical bull run for such things. The bull is coming, but not for those. Even without the regulatory uncertainty, coins aren’t only a massive distraction and significant threat to a gaming company’s business, but are proving themselves to be long-term bad bets. 

[Obviously none of this is financial advice.] 

First, let’s take a look at why coins seemed so attractive a few years ago: 

  1. For developers, they were a relatively easy way to raise money from a mix of institutions and consumers hopping on the hype train. They were also a way to cash out on vesting faster than traditional equity. 
  2. For investors, the theory was, they were an immediately-liquid form of investment, as opposed to traditional equity which requires some kind of exit (acquisition or IPO). 
  3. For consumers, it was another bout of get-rich-quickery and, not as often, a feeling of “investing” in a game’s future. The degen crypto trader crowd weren’t die-hard gamers, but were willing to make money off them. 

These coins also exposed some odd hypocrisy. In lots of cases, the developers insisted that they would be “utility tokens,” i.e. usable in-game for purchasing items, etc. Which was kind of bizarre coming from a crowd that was against the idea of web2’s closed ecosystems where Fortnite Vbucks had no value in Roblox, for example. These tokens are fungible, and while SAND can be swapped into GALA, each coin universe was essentially saying, “It’s our currency or nada.” Not exactly an open world of seamlessly transferable assets. 

But very quickly, developers and investors alike realized some uncomfortable truths: 

  • Regulations make it incredibly hard to bake in usage for a coin in-game.
    • Not much utility when you can’t use the coin for anything.
    • The investor-y language around the launches puts these coins in even greater regulatory peril as securities.  
  • Coins move relative to the macro crypto market (up until now, we’ll get into this more) and not the usability of the token.
    • The value lives and dies by forces that are uncontrollable. Unlike a stock, where macro conditions can be amazing for some, poor for others (like how leisurewear companies thrived during the pandemic but hotels certainly did not), when crypto winter occurred, every coin went with it. 
  • Coin management and investor relations take significant time away from more important things.
    • A Discord filled with angry consumer investors asking, “Wen moon,” or a marketing plan focused more on pumping token price and not the game, is not a good use of anyone’s time. 
    • If you’ve got good VCs, they normally give you money, provide guidance, and then wait in the wings to offer support when needed. Those are investors game developers want. But consumer token investors want the world, and they want it now. A great way to kill anticipatory excitement. 
    • Lots of developers also set up DAOs or DAO-like structures that would allow for the community of holders to make decisions on game design. Nothing says “this game will be horrible and never launch” quite like design by committee. 
  • Coins don’t reflect the fundamental value of a company.
    • When your company’s market cap is wrapped up in a coin you can’t easily control, compared to equity, it sets up a trough of despair that’s hard to work out of. 
    • Teammates whose compensation includes worthless tokens aren’t going to be extra motivated. 
  • Price fluctuations turn people off.
    • There’s a reason why $1 doesn’t equal 1 Vbuck. That’s just F2P economics 101. 
    • So players already don’t want to see something cost $10, but—even if the coin is doing well—don’t want to see it cost 0.000947 Ape either. One layer of price abstraction is fine. Two is not, especially when it comes with daily changes that users will have to convert themselves (or the developer risks exposing fiat values which won’t be in their economy’s best interest). 

And even as the prices of Bitcoin and Ethereum have started to rally, sentiment still seems sour on early gaming coins, who have all followed similarly poor trajectories in underperforming the market.  

Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin - Sam Barberie
Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin - Sam Barberie 5
Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin - Sam Barberie
Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin - Sam Barberie 6
Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin - Sam Barberie
Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin - Sam Barberie 7

Even if the token price stays decent, coins complicate later investments, exits, and consumer choices:

  • Reducing options for other outside investment.
    • Traditional investors in later rounds might not want to compete with supposed carve-outs for token holders, while coin holders will push back against a two-tier system. 
  • Cutting off acquisition routes.
    • Public companies, especially, don’t want to acquire studios with regulatory baggage. 
  • Consumer expectations.
    • As many games increasingly support multiple chains or use tech like LayerZero, games that stick to their coin economies will be behind the curve of what players expect to see.
    • Likewise with fiat on-ramps and direct purchase trending to the norm, many users won’t expect to see a crypto currency at all. 

Coins aren’t the only alternative fundraising route that developers have tried. Pre-product mints of NFTs, while having some benefits over coins, have largely followed similar trajectories: 

  1. They’re normally bought by investors, not real players.
  2. Their floor prices mimic the larger NFT trading market cycle, not anticipation for the game. 
  3. High initial mint prices always fall dramatically as they converge on a normal game access pass, angering holders. 
  4. Mints also come with the same community management challenges of coins. Lots of TLC for angry voices, not a lot of true community building or development focus. 

But NFTs have some key differences: 

  1. Their regulatory standing (not as likely to be considered securities).
  2. They’re much easier to bring in as fundamentally utile pieces of the game. 

More and more, however, we’re seeing free mints—both limited and unlimited—as a powerful way for developers to rally a community and earn some money through secondary trades. While free or extremely low cost mints don’t net developers the amount of building funds they want, they’re strong indicators of interest that can be put in front of publishers or other investors (similar to web2’s email signups). They also go a long way to build goodwill with future players, reach a larger potential audience in the pre-product phases, and don’t come with the same outsize expectations and distracting maintenance needs as high-priced drops and/or coins. 

The loss of coin launches as a viable option will mean the end for some new studios, full stop. As harsh as it sounds, however, that’s not only expected but also probably as it should be. The world’s best games haven’t been greenlit through speculative investment vehicles. And crowdfunding in general has a dicey history, like Star Citizen’s wildly successful Kickstarter and subsequent $500M in funding, which still hasn’t gotten anyone any playable game in a decade.   

I’m a firm believer that good games can come from anywhere and should have multiple ways of getting made, but I’ll leave you all with this: coins ain’t it. 

Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin - Sam Barberie
Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin – Sam Barberie

Sam Barberie is a gaming and web3 exec based in NY. He was part of the founding team of SuperData Research, which was acquired by Nielsen in 2018; an executive at Animoca Brands; and a consultant and advisor to several blockchain gaming companies. 

Play To Earn Games News

Thanks for taking the time to read this news story on PlayToEarnGames.com. We have all of the latest crypto news about cryptocurrencies, blockchain, web3, and play-to-earn. Our platform is all about keeping you up to date on the newest and best play-to-earn games out there. On our website, you can find in-depth reviews, interesting videos, and detailed articles about the newest and most exciting P2E games for multiple platforms.

We tell you everything you need to know to get the most out of your game time. If you want to learn more about a certain game, you can look at game tokens, white papers, and social media sites that are related to that game.

We are proud to keep our readers up to date on the latest changes in the gaming industry, such as new developments in blockchain technology, non-fungible tokens (NFTs), cryptocurrencies, Web3 innovations, and interesting metaverse games. Check out our “Best Games” and “Game Lists” sections to learn more about the best P2E games and game developers. In the “Video Game News” section, where we post updates every day, you can find out what’s going on in the gaming world.

If you are launching a game or have news about PlayToEarn games, please send us a press release. Our team of dedicated PlayToEarn Game news reporters will be happy to cover your news or event. Our website and reviews of video games are meant to help you find the best play-to-earn (P2E) games out there. We’re glad you chose to come to PlayToEarnGames.com. If you like watching our videos about gaming news or P2E games, you can see them all here. Check out our list of Web3 games to find the one you like best, or the best play to earn games list, or an overview of all the crypto game news 2023.

Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin – Sam Barberie

If you like this game, share it with your friends:

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
WhatsApp
Telegram
Pinterest
Skype
VK
Email

Find our Best P2E Games list. All games are included with reviews and links to the game review page. Have Fun!

More Games

Related P2E Games: Play To Earn Crypto, NFT, Web3

FOTA – Fight of the Ages – Game Review

FOTA (Fight of the Ages) is poised to make a splash in the cryptocurrency gaming market as the first game to offer a truly immersive metaverse experience. This is made possible by the fact that FOTA is designed as a mixed reality (MR) game, which combines elements of both virtual and physical reality to create a fully interactive and seamless gaming environment. Players will be able to explore, battle, and interact with one another in a way that feels both real and fantastical, making FOTA a truly one-of-a-kind gaming experience. FOTA allows players to explore the 3D game world on any platform that is compatible, making it accessible to a wide range of players regardless of their preferred device or operating system. In order to appeal to as many players as possible, the developers of FOTA have created versions of the game for multiple platforms using the Unity 3D game engine. This means that the game will be available on Mac, Windows, Android, and iOS, as well as through the WebGL API in modern web browsers. No matter what device or operating system you prefer, you’ll be able to play FOTA and enjoy all that it has to offer. With this level of accessibility and flexibility, players can choose to play the game in whatever way works best for them. FOTA- Fight of the Ages Gameplay: Mixed reality is a powerful tool, but it’s only effective when used in a way that enhances the gameplay experience. Fortunately, Fight Of The Ages appears to have identified a gaming market that is well-suited for this new technology. The game itself is a top-quality multiplayer online battle arena title with a range of game modes to suit different player preferences. Whether you prefer fast-paced action or strategic planning, FOTA has something for you. With its innovative use of mixed reality and its focus on delivering a thrilling and engaging gameplay experience, FOTA is poised to become a leader in the cryptocurrency gaming market. Players can explore Greenland, The Earth, and The Nightmare, the game’s three main areas, in a 30-level campaign mode that is quest-driven. Players must complete tasks in various worlds to receive rewards in the form of experience points and the game’s native FOTA tokens. Additionally, there are plans to host unique monthly and seasonal missions with new obstacles and even better rewards.

Read Game Review »

Alien Worlds – P2E NFT Game on WAX Blockchain – Game Review

Alien Worlds is a NFT card game where you explore new planets in search of new lifeforms. Find out about the Play-to-Earn game Alien Worlds on the WAX Blockchain! Explore six different worlds, each of which has 500 plots of land owned by the NFT. Trilium can be earned in-game, sent to Binance Smart Chain, and bet on for even better benefits. This book tells you everything you need to know to get started in the Alien Worlds metaverse. Are you ready to start your Play-to-Earn journey in Alien Worlds and see what it has to offer? This guide will teach you how to play Alien Worlds and how to get Trilium tokens by mining on land plots owned by other players, getting NFT points, and joining Syndicates to vote on plans. The game play in Alien Worlds is easy but exciting. Players can mine on land plots with their Shovel or other mining-related NFTs and get a small number of Trilium pieces in return. At the same time, miners get NFT points every time they mine. These points can be used to buy a rotating collection of NFTs, such as Land Plots, Tools, Minions, Avatars, and Weapons, which all live on the WAX blockchain. In Alien Worlds, a person owns each piece of land. That player gets a share of the Trilium mined on their land. On top of all of this are the Syndicates, which are player-run planetary governments that can submit and vote on ideas for their planet’s Alien Worlds environment. This makes the game even more strategic and involves the whole group. Alien Worlds is one of the older WAX games, and since it was first announced in July 2020, it has changed all the time. In October, they sold several NFTs, and in December of that same year, they sold their first and only piece of land. Soon after the land was sold, people could start mining on land plots. Since then, the team has been slowly and steadily improving their website and adding new features. Alien Worlds is part of the Blockchain Games Alliance, a group of game creators and players who want to see more blockchain-based games made and played.

Read Game Review »

Splinterlands: Metaverse Trading Card Game – Game Review

Splinterlands is a dynamic and rapidly expanding trading card game set within a continually growing metaverse. This thrilling game allows players to assemble, trade, and engage in battles using their personalized decks, comprising an assortment of monsters, spells, and special abilities. With its high-speed gameplay and a diverse selection of gaming modes, Splinterlands caters to both seasoned trading card game enthusiasts and newcomers. NFTs in Splinterlands: The game employs non-fungible tokens (NFTs) to represent digital cards during intense battles among players. This unique combination of fast-paced action and NFT integration distinguishes Splinterlands as a one-of-a-kind and exhilarating gaming experience. As the game continues to expand and develop, players can eagerly anticipate the addition of more content and features, making it an ever-evolving and captivating choice for gamers.

Gameplay and Objectives: In Splinterlands, players aim to accumulate the highest number of points by vanquishing opponents and completing objectives. This ever-expansive and fast-paced metaverse trading card game provides players with the opportunity to trade at their convenience, engage in battles with adversaries, and earn real money with each victory. With its wide array of game modes and continuously evolving content, Splinterlands offers limitless entertainment and challenges suitable for players of all skill levels. The game presents an opportunity to become a top player and earn substantial rewards.

NFTs in Splinterlands: Splinterlands employs non-fungible tokens (NFTs) to represent digital cards, creating a distinct metaverse for players to engage in battles. Set within a world characterized by blood and power, participants must vie for control and survival by harnessing primal energies and diverse manas. The game offers a fast-paced gaming experience with a variety of game modes to select from, immersing players in an exhilarating environment.

In-Game Tokens: New players can enter the game with a relatively low investment of $10, acquiring a spellbook to begin their journey. Splinterlands utilizes its native token, SPS, and operates on Hive blockchain technology. Additionally, it features DEC (Dark Energy Crystals), an in-game currency that players can use to purchase in-game assets. The game’s standout feature is its quick battles, which require minimal time commitment compared to other games. Furthermore, Splinterlands undergoes constant development and expansion, boasting 500 cards and over 64 associated abilities as of the latest update.

Accessibility for All Players: Splinterlands is designed to offer an equitable gaming experience for both novices and seasoned players. Newcomers can earn new cards and tokens by completing quests, participating in ranked matches, or joining tournaments. The game’s digital cards can be traded on a secondary market and subsequently converted into cryptocurrency, enabling players to reap real-world rewards for their in-game achievements. Founded in 2018 by Matthew Rosen and Jesse Reich with initial funding of $3.6 million, Splinterlands has evolved into a popular and exhilarating gaming venture, providing players with the chance to collect and trade digital cards while earning tangible rewards.

Read Game Review »

Dark Country – Game Review

Dark Country is a gothic game that is uniquely American, allowing players to create, own, and manage non-fungible tokens (NFTs) with complete transparency. In Dark Country, you can customize your own deck of cards featuring creatures, spells, and skills to use in different game modes. Each card in your deck is owned solely by you, and can be altered, upgraded, traded, or destroyed at any time by you or other players. Dark Country offers various game modes that can increase the value of your NFT cards. You can challenge your friends, the AI, or other random players to test your gaming abilities and earn in-game SDM tokens. Please note that every game you play will consume resources within the game. Dark Country Gameplay and the Lore: Dark Country is set in the fictional, gothic world of “Dark Country.” The story begins with the Chief summoning the ancestral guard, but instead, he unleashes a great evil. Four factions – cowboys, criminals, Indians, and zombie demons – roam the land, and players can choose one of these groups as their heroes and build their decks by adding more cards to their inventory. In Dark Country, players can engage in both player versus player (PVP) and player versus environment (PVE) battles, as well as participate in tournaments using classic card-trading battle mechanics. Players also have the option to own land and can earn rewards for developing their “hometown,” such as the ability to craft new cards, join different groups, and embark on new adventures, all of which can yield additional prizes. Dark Country connects the elements of ownership and earning by allowing players to earn an income through completing expeditions and other in-game activities. Players can also make money passively by renting out their land and lending out their NFT cards, as well as by participating in various in-game activities. The game also offers decentralized finance (DeFi) products, such as staking and farming NFTs.

Read Game Review »

Best P2E Games list 2024

Column: Don’t Get Hoodwinked Into A Coin – Sam Barberie

P2E News, short for “Play-to-Earn News,” is a category of updates and information within the broader spectrum of Crypto News, Web3 News, NFT News, and Blockchain News. These terms are all interconnected and represent various facets of the rapidly evolving digital landscape.

Play-to-Earn (P2E) is a gaming model that has gained immense popularity within the crypto and blockchain communities. In P2E games, players can earn cryptocurrencies or NFTs by participating in the game, often through activities like completing quests, collecting items, or trading assets. P2E News covers developments, announcements, and trends related to these innovative gaming experiences that allow players to monetize their in-game efforts.

Crypto News, on the other hand, focuses on the broader world of cryptocurrencies, including Bitcoin, Ethereum, and a multitude of altcoins. This category encompasses news about market trends, regulatory changes, new blockchain technologies, and updates related to various tokens. Crypto News is a fundamental aspect of the blockchain ecosystem, as cryptocurrencies serve as the primary means of value transfer and exchange within the Web3 space.

Web3 News is an umbrella term that refers to the next-generation internet, often characterized by decentralized applications, blockchain technology, and smart contracts. The Web3 ecosystem seeks to provide a more user-centric and decentralized internet experience. This category of news covers developments in decentralized finance (DeFi), non-fungible tokens (NFTs), and various other applications built on blockchain technology. For the ultimate and best play to earn games list, check our friends of playtoearngames.com.

NFT News focuses on Non-Fungible Tokens, unique digital assets that are indivisible and represent ownership of a specific item, artwork, or collectible. NFTs have gained prominence in the art world, gaming industry, and entertainment sector. NFT News keeps enthusiasts informed about NFT sales, new projects, and partnerships within the NFT space.

Blockchain News pertains to the foundational technology behind cryptocurrencies and Web3 applications. Blockchains are decentralized ledgers that record transactions across a network of computers, ensuring transparency and security. Updates in this category might include innovations in blockchain consensus mechanisms, interoperability between different blockchain networks, and industry applications beyond cryptocurrencies.

In summary, P2E News is a niche subset of Crypto News, Web3 News, NFT News, and Blockchain News. It focuses on gaming experiences where players can earn cryptocurrencies or NFTs, while the other categories encompass a broader range of topics within the decentralized digital landscape, including cryptocurrencies, web3 technologies, NFTs, and blockchain advancements. Collectively, these categories shape the landscape of the digital economy, offering insights into how technology is revolutionizing various aspects of our lives.